Popular HF/6m radios in the $1k to $1.5k range include the Icom IC-7300, Yaesu FT-710, and Yaesu FT-DX10. I'm setting up my first serious HF base station and getting conflicting advice on receiver performance versus published specs. Some operators report the FT-991A digs weak signals out of noise better than the 7300 in high-signal environments, while the 7300 gets overwhelmed and needs RF gain reduction. Sherwood Engineering rates the IC-7300 receiver higher than the FT-991, but some experienced operators can't tell the difference in real-world conditions. What's your actual operating experience with these rigs?

I recommend the Icom IC-7300 for new hams - it's easy to use and setup, has a built-in sound card, and the best metering for digital modes. The waterfall display is incredibly useful for finding clear frequencies during contests.

I've owned both radios for contesting. The FT-991A has better tools to fight QRM/QRN, and when you want to dig out a small signal from the noise, the 991A will be better. The 7300's display is prettier, but I buy transceivers for performance, not displays.

As a newer General class operator, I'd get the IC-7300 if you don't need 2m/70cm SSB - the 7300 is easier to use menu-wise and has a better display. The learning curve is much gentler for beginners.